In the May 19, 2014 J.P. v. Division of Medical Assistance and Health Services decision, New Jersey’s Appellate Division affirmed the final agency decision of the Director of the Division of Medical Assistance and Health Services (“DMAHS”), resulting in the imposition of a transfer penalty on the petitioner’s Medicaid application.
After the ALJ had accepted the Medicaid applicant’s claim that transfers from the applicant were reimbursements of nursing services and repayment of loans, rather than gifts, the DMAHS Director had reversed and imposed a Medicaid penalty. The Director had found that the applicant failed to prove that the transfers were not made for the purpose of acquiring Medicaid eligibility. The Director had found that the note allegedly evidencing the debt was not executed contemporaneously with the loan, bore only an unauthenticated signature, and omitted key provisions, such as a repayment date or interest rate. It remained unenforced for fifteen years, until the applicant entered the nursing home. With regard to the alleged nursing care provided by the applicant’s daughters, there was no contract to show that the services were intended to be compensated.
After commending the Medicaid Director for “carefully considering” the evidence, the Appellate Division affirmed the Director’s decision. Significantly, the Appellate Division opinion concludes by downplaying the deference owed to an ALJ, and emphasizing the deference owed to the Medicaid Director: “We owe substantial deference to the decisions of the administrative agency, not the findings of an ALJ.” The Appellate Division continued that an ALJ is given special deference by the agency and reviewing court “only regarding credibility determinations made based on live testimony.” The Medicaid agency, in turn, is free to reject an ALJ decision as long as it gives “due consideration” to the ALJ findings, supports its decision with “substantial evidence” in the record, and “indicates how it weighed that evidence.”
A copy of J.P. v. DMAHS can be found here: J.P. v. Division of Medical Assistance and Health Services
For additional information concerning Medicaid and public benefits planning, visit:
https://vanarellilaw.com/medicaid-public-benefits-planning/
Categories
- Affordable Care Act
- Alzheimer's Disease
- Arbitration
- Attorney Ethics
- Attorneys Fees
- Beneficiary Designations
- Blog Roundup and Highlights
- Blogs and Blogging
- Care Facilities
- Caregivers
- Cemetery
- Collaborative Family Law
- Conservatorships
- Consumer Fraud
- Contempt
- Contracts
- Defamation
- Developmental Disabilities
- Discovery
- Discrimination Laws
- Doctrine of Probable Intent
- Domestic Violence
- Elder Abuse
- Elder Law
- Elective Share
- End-of-Life Decisions
- Estate Administration
- Estate Litigation
- Estate Planning
- Events
- Family Law
- Fiduciary
- Financial Exploitation of the Elderly
- Funeral
- Future of the Legal Profession
- Geriatric Care Managers
- Governmental or Public Benefit Programs
- Guardianship
- Health Issues
- Housing for the Elderly and Disabled
- In Remembrance
- Insolvent Estates
- Institutional Liens
- Insurance
- Interesting New Cases
- Intestacy
- Law Firm News
- Law Firm Videos
- Law Practice Management / Development
- Lawyers and Lawyering
- Legal Capacity or Competancy
- Legal Malpractice
- Legal Rights of the Disabled
- Liens
- Litigation
- Mediation
- Medicaid Appeals
- Medicaid Applications
- Medicaid Planning
- Annuities
- Care Contracts
- Divorce
- Estate Recovery
- Family Part Non-Dissolution Support Orders
- Gifts
- Life Estates
- Loan repayments
- MMMNA
- Promissory Notes
- Qualified Income Trusts
- Spousal Refusal
- Transfers For Reasons Other Than To Qualify For Medicaid
- Transfers to "Caregiver" Child(ren)
- Transfers to Disabled Adult Children
- Trusts
- Undue Hardship Provision
- Multiple-Party Deposit Account Act
- New Cases
- New Laws
- News Briefs
- Newsletters
- Non-Probate Assets
- Nursing Facility Litigation
- Personal Achievements and Awards
- Personal Injury Lawsuits
- Probate
- Punitive Damages
- Reconsideration
- Retirement Benefits
- Reverse Mortgages
- Section 8 Housing
- Settlement of Litigation
- Social Media
- Special Education
- Special Needs Planning
- Surrogate Decision-Making
- Taxation
- Technology
- Texting
- Top Ten
- Trials
- Trustees
- Uncategorized
- Veterans Benefits
- Web Sites and the Internet
- Webinar
- Writing Intended To Be A Will
Vanarelli & Li, LLC on Social Media